Captain D's

🍽️ Restaurants · Columbus

20

total experiences

85%

replied on google

Most reported issues

AI-classified. Tap a category to filter the experiences below.

Experiences

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jul 19, 2026

Long wait times and poor staff attitude at drive thru

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Jul 15, 2026

Staff member provided poor service and refused to complete the order

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jun 27, 2026

Staff were unable to process a gift card purchase.

Business reply on Google

Hi Wil, it's disappointing to hear about the trouble with your gift card purchase. We're dedicated to enhancing our service and appreciate your input. If you need more help, please visit https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/.

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
May 10, 2026

Staff refused coupon and displayed unprofessional appearance and attitude.

Business reply on Google

Hi Sam, your feedback is important to us, and we're sorry for the experience you had. We will work on ensuring a better experience for our guests. Please reach out at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ if you wish to discuss further.

WorstCleanliness & HygieneFrom Google Reviews
Apr 21, 2026

The restaurant has an unpleasant odor.

Business reply on Google

Hi Jonathan, your feedback is important to us, and we're dedicated to making improvements. For further details, please reach out at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/. We value your insights.

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Apr 15, 2026

A male employee speaks disrespectfully to the staff.

Business reply on Google

Hi Lisa, your feedback is important to us, and we're sorry for the experience you had. We are committed to ensuring a respectful environment for all. Please reach out to us at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ to discuss this further.

WorstProduct / Service QualityFrom Google Reviews
Feb 17, 2026

Catfish sandwiches were inedible due to excessive salt content.

Business reply on Google

Hi Nancy, we're sorry to hear about your experience with the catfish sandwiches and the difficulty reaching us. Your feedback is important, and we are committed to improving our service. Please reach out to us at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ so we can address your concerns directly.

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Oct 1, 2025

Manager was disrespectful and attempted to overcharge for a meal.

Business reply on Google

We appreciate your feedback and are sorry to hear about your experience. Providing respectful and attentive service is important to us, and we regret that this was not reflected during your visit. Your comments will be shared with our team to help us improve. Please feel free to reach out to us directly at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ so we can address your concerns further.

WorstProduct / Service QualityFrom Google Reviews
Sep 12, 2025

The fish dinner was overcooked, flavorless, and poorly prepared.

Business reply on Google

We appreciate your feedback and are sorry to hear about your experience. We strive to provide delicious and flavorful meals, and it seems we missed the mark during your visit. Your comments will be shared with our team to help us improve. Please feel free to reach out to us directly at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ so we can address your concerns further.

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Aug 6, 2025

The night shift staff were rude and ungrateful to the customer.

Business reply on Google

We appreciate your feedback and are sorry to hear about your experience at our Macon Rd location. We strive to provide a welcoming and friendly environment for all our guests and will address your concerns with our team. Your input is valuable to us as we work to improve. Please feel free to reach out to us directly at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ for further assistance.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jun 5, 2025

Rude staff provided poor service and incorrect order charges

Business reply on Google

We're truly sorry to hear about your experiences at our location. We strive to provide top-notch service and it's clear we missed the mark in your case. We take your feedback seriously and will use it to improve. We hope you'll give us another chance to make things right. Please share more details at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ so we can address this issue properly.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Dec 22, 2022

Staff failed to provide manager name and incorrectly fulfilled food order.

Business reply on Google

Melissa, we're so sorry this was your experience at our Columbus Captain D's store. Can you reach out to us at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ and share a few more details? We’d love to follow up with you directly.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Nov 23, 2022

The business provides unclear information regarding holiday operating hours.

Business reply on Google

John, we're sincerely sorry to hear about this experience. That doesn’t sound good. Can you reach out to us at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ and share a few more details? We’d love to follow up with you directly.

WorstProduct / Service QualityFrom Google Reviews
Oct 29, 2022

Food was cold and a foreign object was found in order.

Business reply on Google

We're sincerely sorry to hear this and thank you for bringing this to our attention. We take this seriously and will pass along your message to the management team for the Columbus Captain D's. If you’d like to share more details, please reach out to us at https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/

WorstProduct / Service QualityFrom Google Reviews
Oct 8, 2021

Incomplete order received with undercooked food items.

Business reply on Google

Tracey – Oh no! We are sorry to hear that. Please go to https://www.captainds.com/contact-us/ and provide us with some details on your experience and someone from guest services will reach out as soon as possible.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Apr 13, 2021

Manager refused to resolve missing items from an online order.

WorstRefund & ReturnFrom Google Reviews
Feb 27, 2021

restaurant failed to refund cancelled online order and provided poor service

Business reply on Google

Jennifer – Oh no! We are sorry to hear that. Please go to contact.captainds.com and provide us with some details on your experience and someone from guest services will reach out as soon as possible.

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Feb 2, 2021

Staff member was rude and refused to provide requested condiment.

Business reply on Google

Nicole – Oh no! We are sorry to hear that. Please go to contact.captainds.com and provide us with some details on your experience and someone from guest services will reach out as soon as possible.

WorstProduct / Service QualityFrom Google Reviews
Aug 28, 2019

food served cold and order accuracy issues at multiple locations

Business reply on Google

keekee – Oh no! We are sorry to hear that. Please go to contact.captainds.com and provide us with some details on your experience and someone from guest services will reach out as soon as possible.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Apr 12, 2019

Incorrect order and poor customer service from management

Business reply on Google

Elaine – Oh no! We are sorry you had that experience. Please go to contact.captainds.com and provide us with some details and someone from guest services will reach out as soon as possible.