Cold Stone Creamery

🍽️ Restaurants · Hackettstown

18

total experiences

6%

replied on google

Most reported issues

AI-classified. Tap a category to filter the experiences below.

Experiences

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Aug 2, 2026

Store closes earlier than the posted operating hours

Business reply on Google

Hi Joseph, We’re sorry your visit didn’t go as you expected. When a location closes earlier than advertised, it creates a frustrating experience—especially when you’ve tried to stop by multiple times. We appreciate you taking the time to share this, and we’ll review the situation with the team so the hours you see match what guests can expect. If you’d like to report the details of the visit, please use: www.coldstonecreamery.com/contactus Warm regards, Cold Stone Creamery

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Jul 4, 2026

The staff was rude and the ice cream is overpriced.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Oct 13, 2025

staff failed to acknowledge or serve customer in empty store

WorstBilling & ChargesFrom Google Reviews
Mar 17, 2025

misleading pricing and poor staff customer service

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jan 12, 2025

Store hours listed online do not match actual operating hours.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
May 13, 2024

Employee locked the store and stopped serving customers before closing time.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Mar 23, 2024

The business was closed before the posted closing time.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Mar 4, 2024

Staff refused to properly replace an incorrectly prepared ice cream order.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Feb 11, 2024

Staff refused service and displayed poor attitude before official closing time.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Aug 7, 2023

High prices, dirty floors, and long wait times due to understaffing.

WorstProduct / Service QualityFrom Google Reviews
Jul 7, 2023

Ice cream was melted due to broken freezers and gift card rejected.

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Jun 4, 2023

Staff member was rude and ignored the customer during the order.

WorstStaff BehaviorFrom Google Reviews
Sep 5, 2022

Staff refused to make milkshakes to avoid cleaning the machine.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jul 19, 2022

The business closed earlier than the hours listed online.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jul 12, 2022

The business closes earlier than the posted operating hours.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Dec 16, 2020

Staff were inattentive and failed to provide information about included toppings.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Jun 15, 2019

Staff provided poorly prepared drinks and insufficient portion sizes.

WorstCustomer ServiceFrom Google Reviews
Aug 5, 2018

Rude staff and melted ice cream served at high price